misfitS pOLITICS

We talk. We write. We entertain. Or so we think.
  • Home
  • Home

Unreliable Assumptions

6/2/2017

0 Comments

 
Chad Felix Greene

Skewed LGBT statistics are driving the narrative.

Addressing the way the liberal media reports on the lifestyle conditions and relative happiness of minority groups requires a lot of unpacking. In almost every case the very first hurdle is one of semantics and assumptions. The Left, for example, assumes poverty rather than sees it as a temporary condition. The Left assumes discrimination and merely correlates measurable consequences attributed to it. Most importantly, the Left assumes government, and positions all current problems in relation to how the government must be more involved. When reporting on LGBT issues, these assumptions create a perfect storm of narrative and drama.
​

A recent survey conducted by the Center for American Progress has begun shaping the narrative around LGBT well-being and equality within liberal media circles. I discussed in some depth why the survey’s original claim that 1 in 4 LGBT experienced discrimination in 2016 was irrational based on the way the survey was conducted previously. The survey was fairly all-inclusive in terms of the impact on the daily lives of the LGBT members it spoke to and thus is beginning to provide fertile ground for even more extreme claims.

One such claim became the foundation of an NBC News article titled: LGBTQ Community Would Be ‘Hard Hit’ by Trump’s 2018 Budget.  Brooke Sopelsa, managing editor of NCB Out, spoke with the associate director of LGBT research at the Center for American Progress, Sharita Gruberg, about the consequences of President Trump’s proposed budget. Gruberg stated: "And because LGBT people face high rates of discrimination that fuels unemployment, poverty and uninsurance, they're going to be particularly hard hit by these cuts to essential programs." Stephen Forssell, director of the Graduate Program in LGBT Health Policy and Practice at George Washington University, said the overall message of Trump's budget proposal is "it's open season on marginalized populations."

​Neither of these statements is rational. But the underlying assumption being made here is "marginalized populations" are heavily dependent on government aid in order to survive and therefore any attempt to balance the budget will directly harm them. It is simply assumed that restructuring Medicaid’s budget “…will be detrimental to the ability of people living with HIV to get the health care they need to survive." for example. While, as Ben Shapiro reasons, “…Trump’s budget would allow states to add work requirements to entitlement programs and bar funding to illegal immigrants through federal tax credits.” while articulating that actual savings is unlikely. The Left and the Right are viewing two radically different outcomes and the Left is validating its own fears and paranoia as a result.

Here are some of the statistics Sopelsa provides us:
  • 18% of LGBT have Medicaid.
  • 27% of LGBT participate in the SNAP food program.
  • LGBT are three times as likely to suffer from mental illness.
  • 28% of gay and lesbian, and 50% of transgender people have been discriminated against in employment.
Most strikingly, Gruberg states, "More than one in four LGBT adults reported that they didn't have enough money to feed themselves or their families in the past year."

Here are some other statistics that may help shed some light:
  • Between 39% and 67% of transgender individuals report engaging in sex work.
  • 1/3rd of gay men and 2/3rds of lesbians have drinking problems.
  • 39% of LGBT report drug abuse.
  • 27% of LGBT are smokers.
  • 23% of gay men, 36% of lesbian women and 40% of bisexual women are obese.
  • According to the CDC 26% of gay men, 37.3% of bisexual men report rape, physical assault, or stalking by same-sex partners, with 43.8% of lesbians, 61.1% of bisexual women reporting.

​Assumptions can be made using any one, or combination of, these numbers. You could speculate that due to the high smoking rate (
smokers are less likely to be hired and earn less money) and drinking concerns of LGBT, employment sustainability and access would be limited solely on those two factors. You could argue that high mental illness coupled with high drug abuse contributes to irrational, unhealthy decision-making which, naturally, impacts work and social life. Every article cited chooses to assume the underlying cause of all of the above-mentioned problems comes solely from "discrimination and hate." What is ignored, however, is the roughly 75% of LGBT who seem to be doing just fine.


While it seems unreasonable that being LGBT would make it difficult to find enough to eat, assuming this is true it in no way implies an anti-LGBT root. It is far more likely that there is a large amount of crossover between those abusing drugs and alcohol, suffering from mental illness, and other forms of abuse from partners and relying on government resources and LGBT organizations for survival. It is this population that skews the surveys. LGBT related surveys rarely attribute co-factors into their results, tending to simply ask about one particularly negative scenario or feeling and then reporting the numbers.

The population that should be researched is the much larger number of average, everyday LGBT that live their lives without any of these concerns. LGBT that do not abuse drugs and alcohol, are responsible adults, law-abiding, and concerned more with their kids or mortgages, represent life for LGBT in America far more accurately. To simply assert that 25% of the LGBT population provides insight into the overall experience of LGBT in America is absurd, especially when ignoring the obvious co-factors.

While LGBT tend to argue that it is the result of discrimination, harassment and generalized "hate" that causes these profound societal problems, they never address how it is that most LGBT, who must be experiencing the same discrimination, harassment, and hate, build perfectly functional and productive lives. How does one gay person manage their education and finances, maintain good health, and become an active part of society while another becomes a sex worker,  drug abuser trapped in poverty? The answer has absolutely nothing to do with the fact that they are both gay.

Interestingly, gay male couples have consistently made more money than straight married couples with gay men earning an average of $176,000 a year. Gay male couples with children earn an average of $275,000. Gay men are also more highly educated. Somehow, we are to believe that being gay makes one more likely to experience discrimination, be denied promotions, or make as much as their straight counterparts.

Medicaid should be handled by the states and it is perfectly reasonable for each state to determine how to best provide these services. There is no specific cut to LGBT people receiving Medicaid and restructuring the budget in no way means people will be denied coverage if they need it. HIV care is handled by the Ryan White Foundation as well as Medicaid, but to pretend that any cuts to Medicaid would deny LGBT access to HIV care is unfounded speculation. In my personal experience doctors will go out of their way to ensure patients have access to the medications they need regardless of payment ability for as long as they can. This is a cruel scare-tactic with no real foundation.

Truth be told what we are seeing here is a population of LGBT Americans dependent on the government. We are also seeing a population of LGBT Americans addicted to drugs and alcohol, suffering from mental illness, engaging in extremely risky lifestyle behaviors, and violently attacking their partners. It is reasonable to see the overlap of these two populations and understand why dismissal of responsibility alongside continued demands for more government involvement will only exaggerate the problem.

What is not apparent, however, is that any of these things have to do with being LGBT or the larger social acceptance of LGBT. With the vast majority of LGBT never experiencing anything close to discrimination, harassment, or hate in our everyday lives, it should matter to us that our media report such misleading and fear-mongering articles. Why is it so important for them to have a population afraid, paranoid, and fighting imaginary demons while ignoring the very real demons within the community itself?

Finally, why isn’t the largely wealthy LGBT community contributing to charities designed to help people escape sex work, drug abuse, abusive relationships, and build meaningful, productive lives in society? All the anti-LGBT discrimination laws, protections, and proclamations will be meaningless if a person cannot obtain a job because of drug use or prostitution. Allowing a drug user to blame society doesn’t help anyone either. Straight people are not the biggest threat to the LGBT community; LGBT people themselves are. Nothing will improve for that 25% until this is recognized and acted upon.

​For more from Chad, visit chadfelixgreene.com and follow him on Twitter @chadfelixg.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Misfits

    Just a gaggle of people from all over who have similar interests and loud opinions mixed with a dose of humor. We met on Twitter.
    ​Enough said.

    (If that's not enough, you can learn more here)

    Tweets by misfitspolitics

    Archives

    January 2024
    November 2023
    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016

    Categories

    All
    2016
    9/11
    Abortion
    AFB
    Afghanistan
    Air Force
    #alfieevans
    Alfie Evans
    ALS
    Armed Forces
    Army
    Baby
    Ben Carson
    Bernie
    Blog
    Bosnia
    CAOC
    #CelebrateWomen
    Christie
    City Council
    Comey
    Cooking
    Crete
    Cruz
    Deep Fry
    Desert Storm
    Donald Trump
    Drug Companies
    Election
    England
    Europe
    Exclusivity
    F-16
    Fanfic
    Fayetteville
    FBI
    FDA
    Fiction
    Fire
    Florida
    Free Market
    Fun
    Germany
    Gilmore
    Government
    Health Care
    Hillary Clinton
    Hobby
    Iraq
    Italy
    John Kasich
    Kevin Williamson
    Korea
    Kuwait
    LANTIRN
    Life
    Local Politics
    Marco Rubio
    Medical Care
    Memoir
    Military
    MIsfitMemo
    #MisfitMemo
    Misfits
    Misfits Politics
    Moms
    Mother's Day
    Narrative
    National Review
    NATO
    Navy
    #NeverTrump
    Patent
    Pharmaceutical
    Philippines
    Phillippines
    Politics
    Raymond
    Reform
    Rex
    Rubio
    Scarcity
    September 11th
    Service
    Ted Cruz
    Thread
    Tweetstorm
    Twitter
    UK
    Water
    Weekly Rewind
    World Cup
    World Trade Center

    RSS Feed

Home

About

Contact​

Copyright © 2016
  MisfitsPolitics
  • Home
  • Home