misfitS pOLITICS

We talk. We write. We entertain. Or so we think.
  • Home
  • Home

The GOP’s Wasted Estate Tax Opposition

10/3/2016

2 Comments

 
Alexandra F. Baldwin
I had a somewhat animated discussion a couple of weeks ago with a couple of Twitter buddies about the federal “Death Tax” (more completely described as the unified lifetime gift and estate tax.) My initial assertion included two parts:

1)      It is a terrible tax
2)      The Republican party’s staunch opposition to it makes little sense

The reaction was swift and focused entirely on the second part of that (so much so that I think they kinda missed the first part). I got a “No, it isn’t” (referring to the GOP’s opposition, not my assessment of the quality of the tax) and a “Should people be able to keep the fruits of their labor?” And then, of course, I got the standard go-to opposition to the Estate Tax…”Think of the family farmers!”

But here’s the thing: almost nobody pays it. The GOP has devoted significant energy and political capital to criticizing a tax that impacts nobody who is not, by any definition, spectacularly wealthy. And then they wonder why the “Party of the rich” criticism sticks…

On the surface, the Federal tax (which reaches a top rate of 40%) seems quite punitive, and also seems like it immediately sucks up the wealth of a hardworking American who simply wants to pass some money, a home, or some other assets to his children. It is also often cited as an economic attack on the wealthy, intended to seize wealth at death and distribute it from wealthy to non-wealthy (i.e., people who die with nothing and are unaffected).

It is, however, not a tax on the wealthy. It is a tax on the children of the wealthy. And realistically, it is a tax on the children of the super-wealthy.

Let's walk through a somewhat typical example to see how this tax might impact someone...

My husband and I have two children who turned six in April. Let's imagine that I have a large estate, and I am not excited by the idea that the Federal Government is going to take 40% of that before my children can get it (I am ignoring state taxes, which are not insignificant).

{Since the limits below are inflation-adjusting, I am just going to do the whole thing in today's dollars. I am also going to ignore investment gains, which should be pretty easy to understand.}

There is good news, though!

I can give each of the children $14,000 every single year without paying any gift tax or without using any of my lifetime exemption (more on that below). Even better, my husband can also give them each $14,000 every single year without incurring any gift tax. I am going to ignore non-children here, but we are also allowed to each give $14,000 every single year to anyone else (brothers, sisters, cousins, nieces, nephews, friends...) without incurring any gift tax.

My life expectancy at this point is probably another 50 years. My husband's is probably 45 years. So, just through those annual gifts, we would be able to pass $2.66 million to our two daughters without anyone paying a penny of transfer tax. Of course, they may get married, at which point each of my husband and I can also give their spouse $14,000 per year. Grandchildren? $14,000 per year, per child from each grandparent. If they each marry at 30 and have two kids each? About $1.8 million additionally to the families of each daughter.

But we’re not done yet! Next, we can pay an unlimited amount for medical or education expenses...which means we can gift a college and graduate education to our kids and our grandkids without incurring any transfer tax. If I am this rich, that means probably 12 years of private school at $35k/year, four years of private college at $50k/yr and then two years of graduate school at another $50k. There is another $720,000 each (more if they are a doctor or a lawyer!), plus I can absorb the risk of medical expenditures. If we pay for the kids’ school, too, we’re now passed $2.16 million just in education expenses to each of our two daughters and their families.

So, great...now we have given them EACH $5.296 million over the course of our lives without anyone paying anything, and without touching our yet-to-be-discussed lifetime exemption. That is a total of $10.592 million (in today's dollars) just to our children. And if you have more kids than me, it is another $5.296 million per child.

But wait, there's more!!! On top of the annual exclusion, I also get a lifetime exclusion which covers gifts above and beyond what I can give through the annual gifts. This is called a "Unified Credit" because it applies to gifts during my life AND gifts upon my death. In other words, whatever I don't use up during my life is available to apply to the assets I leave for my kids at my death.

Chances are that I will survive my husband, but if I didn’t for some reason, I wouldn't leave anything to my kids at death...I would leave everything to my husband. A transfer to a spouse is a tax-free transfer, regardless of the size. Plus, he can give me his unified credit, which means that, upon his death, both of our unified credits would be available to apply to any assets that get passed to our kids (or anyone else).

The amount of the Unified Credit in 2016? $5.45 million. That's right...whichever of us dies second would have TWO credits of $5.45 million to apply to assets passed to our two children.

This means that, in total, we can pass $10.592 million to our children during our lives, and then we can pass another $10.9 million to them either during our lives or at death before they (or our estates) are liable for the first penny of “Death Tax.”

And obviously, that would be after any gifts we made to other family members or friends within the annual exclusion, or any charitable gifts of any size. If, after I have given my kids their $21.492 million, and after I have given the rest of my family and friends whatever I may have decided to give to them, and after I have given away whatever I have designated for charity, there is still any money left over...well, then my two children would have to pay as much as 40% of the value of that property that was left over.

Actually…wait…that’s not quite true. There’s even more to this, because large fortunes are often passed on to the next generation in the form of illiquid, hard-to-value assets (like, say, a farm), or in the form of “family limited partnerships” or other tax-management schemes. When using things like this, taxpayers are given some latitude in valuing their hard-to-value assets, and are often allowed to lop off as much as 25% of the value as a “control premium” for minority stakes in businesses. In simpler terms, that $21.492 million may actually be worth nearly double that, but we’ve come up with a passable rationale that values the assets at only half of their actual value.

What haven’t we talked about yet? We haven’t given a nickel to charity, nor to anyone who is not our children or their families. We haven’t moved any assets overseas or used any elaborate offshore tax dodges. What we have done is gotten to a point where our $40+ million estate can pass to our children before we, or they, have to pay the first penny of federal estate tax.

Which brings me back to my original point about the GOP’s opposition to the estate tax. They have chosen to dig their heels in and rally their base around an issue that affects only about 1 in 500 estates.  They remain silent on several other broad, egregious examples of double-taxation that impact huge numbers of Americans, including the double taxation of Social Security and Medicare. They take issue occasionally, but with less vigor, with taxes on dividends that impact anyone who has a 401K.

I
f you are trying to shake your reputation as being a party that serves only connected, moneyed interests, you’ve picked a really bad fight.

2 Comments
Jellenne
10/14/2016 08:42:53 pm

Your initial premise is based upon an Estate that is liquid. There are Small Business Owners, whose business is of significant value, but who cannot pass on the 14kgifts etc annually as the liquidity is in the business. Recently proposed changes in the "discounting" of family owned businesses (not just farms but including them) has been challenged. Regulations are currently pending to prevent this process in it's entirety. You're correct that the Death Tax doesn't affect the truly wealthy, but it kills Small Biz owners in the Middle to Upper Middle.

Reply
Alexandra F. Baldwin
10/17/2016 02:54:29 pm

Liquidity is irrelevant.

Three points:

1) Ownership of any business can be passed regardless of liquidity, and within families it would be a simple transaction that benefits further from being a non-controlling interest in a closely-held business. Shares can pass as easily as cash.

2) None of those proposals has much backing (that would change in a Democratic controlled Congress), and I'd revise some of this if they became law (also, I am not aware of anyone proposing a change to the farm exemptions.) But they are not law, and the current law allows all of this.

3) It *does* impact the truly wealthy. It does not impact the middle class, unless we extend the middle class to include people who own businesses worth north of $10 million. Only 20% of American households have a net worth over $400k, and less than .5% are worth more than $10 million, so including owners of 8 figure businesses in "middle class" is, at best, disingenuous.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Misfits

    Just a gaggle of people from all over who have similar interests and loud opinions mixed with a dose of humor. We met on Twitter.
    ​Enough said.

    (If that's not enough, you can learn more here)

    Tweets by misfitspolitics

    Archives

    January 2024
    November 2023
    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016

    Categories

    All
    2016
    9/11
    Abortion
    AFB
    Afghanistan
    Air Force
    #alfieevans
    Alfie Evans
    ALS
    Armed Forces
    Army
    Baby
    Ben Carson
    Bernie
    Blog
    Bosnia
    CAOC
    #CelebrateWomen
    Christie
    City Council
    Comey
    Cooking
    Crete
    Cruz
    Deep Fry
    Desert Storm
    Donald Trump
    Drug Companies
    Election
    England
    Europe
    Exclusivity
    F-16
    Fanfic
    Fayetteville
    FBI
    FDA
    Fiction
    Fire
    Florida
    Free Market
    Fun
    Germany
    Gilmore
    Government
    Health Care
    Hillary Clinton
    Hobby
    Iraq
    Italy
    John Kasich
    Kevin Williamson
    Korea
    Kuwait
    LANTIRN
    Life
    Local Politics
    Marco Rubio
    Medical Care
    Memoir
    Military
    MIsfitMemo
    #MisfitMemo
    Misfits
    Misfits Politics
    Moms
    Mother's Day
    Narrative
    National Review
    NATO
    Navy
    #NeverTrump
    Patent
    Pharmaceutical
    Philippines
    Phillippines
    Politics
    Raymond
    Reform
    Rex
    Rubio
    Scarcity
    September 11th
    Service
    Ted Cruz
    Thread
    Tweetstorm
    Twitter
    UK
    Water
    Weekly Rewind
    World Cup
    World Trade Center

    RSS Feed

Home

About

Contact​

Copyright © 2016
  MisfitsPolitics
  • Home
  • Home