misfitS pOLITICS

We talk. We write. We entertain. Or so we think.
  • Home
  • Misfit Migrants
  • Mess Hall
  • Meet The Misfits
  • Misc. Musings
  • Home
  • Misfit Migrants
  • Mess Hall
  • Meet The Misfits
  • Misc. Musings

The Abortion Dodge

1/25/2017

2 Comments

 
Mo
Yesterday, The Atlantic published an absurd article, which it promoted on Twitter with the headline: “How the ultrasound pushed the idea that a fetus is a person.” In the article, the author offered a confused and scientifically-dubious diatribe on statutes promoting the use of ultrasound imaging for women who are contemplating abortion.

​The article claims that “the current debate shows how effectively politicians have used visual technology to redefine what counts as ‘life.’” And this paragraph in particular perfectly captures the slipperiness of language the Left uses to talk about abortion, in order to avoid the real debate:  

Their sponsors act as if ultrasound images “prove” that a fetus is equivalent to a “baby,” and that pregnant women only have to be shown ultrasound images in order to draw the same conclusion. But the “heartbeat” made visible via ultrasound does not actually demonstrate any decisive change of state in the cell mass that might become a fetus.

This reasoning—that the ultrasound “proves” “that a fetus is equivalent to a ‘baby’”—is entirely backward. It isn’t the ultrasound that proves it. It’s science, and it happens at fertilization.  

Specifically, when the sperm (a sex cell that contains the father’s DNA) fertilizes the egg (a sex cell that contains the mother’s DNA), a “zygote” with a mix of genes inherited from the parents is formed, which becomes a “fetus” at week eight of gestation. The genetic makeup of the zygote/fetus is human and totally distinct from the parents’. The zygote/fetus is a distinct human being. An abortion is the intentional killing of a human being.

Abortion advocates go to great lengths to avoid this basic scientific fact, by relying on word games, euphemisms, and bad logic.   
  • “It’s just a ‘clump of cells’ or a ‘fetus.’” Sure. So what? All humans are clumps of cells. And all fetuses are humans. This is a non sequitur.
  • “So, you’re saying masturbation and menstruation are abortions, then.” No, they’re not. Sperm and eggs are sex cells that contain human DNA, nothing more. They’re not a separate and distinct human being with his own DNA, like a fertilized egg.
  • “Women will be prosecuted for miscarriages.” No, they won’t, just as people don’t get prosecuted for someone else’s death from natural causes.
  • “A zygote or fetus is not a person.” OK.  What’s a person? Where is the line between a person, entitled to protection, and a non-person? At what point is a zygote or fetus imbued with personhood? There’s no clean answer to these questions, at least not without including in the non-person category people who are not unborn humans, like newborn babies. Ironically, this raises the very same sort of metaphysical and moral questions, such as ensoulment, that abortion advocates often insist don’t belong in this debate.   
  • “A zygote or fetus is not independent from the woman.” This is a relative of the “personhood” argument. Newborn babies are dependent too, as are toddlers, elderly people, and people with disabilities, among others. Why does the location of this human being matter?
  • “My body, my choice.” I will say that this argument gets as close to the real debate as an abortion advocate is typically willing to get. Abortion advocates believe the mother’s body takes precedence over the life of the unborn child. My question is why? Why does the woman’s right to an empty uterus override another human being’s right to live?

The question of whether and under what circumstances we should allow the intentional killing of a human being isn’t easy, but it becomes significantly more difficult when abortion advocates try to obfuscate and dodge it. The Atlantic’s article is a terrific illustration of the mental gymnastics involved in avoiding the question. That abortion advocates want to avoid the question demonstrates how uncomfortable they are with the answer.
2 Comments
tryanmax
1/26/2017 02:48:12 pm

Well cataloged! And a great list of succinct retorts to the common talking points. I get so tired of the weaselly word games, I often just disengage. I'm going to make reference to this article in the future instead.

Reply
David O'Connell
7/29/2017 06:09:06 pm

My favorite part of the article you quoted:

"...the cell mass that might become a fetus".

Just what else could it become? An orange? A grapefruit? An F-18 fighter jet?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Misfits

    Just a gaggle of people from all over who have similar interests and loud opinions mixed with a dose of humor. We met on Twitter.
    ​Enough said.

    (If that's not enough, you can learn more here)

    Tweets by misfitspolitics

    Archives

    December 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016

    Categories

    All
    2016
    9/11
    Abortion
    AFB
    Afghanistan
    Air Force
    #alfieevans
    Alfie Evans
    ALS
    Armed Forces
    Army
    Baby
    Ben Carson
    Bernie
    Blog
    Bosnia
    CAOC
    #CelebrateWomen
    Christie
    City Council
    Comey
    Cooking
    Crete
    Cruz
    Deep Fry
    Desert Storm
    Donald Trump
    Drug Companies
    Election
    England
    Europe
    Exclusivity
    F-16
    Fanfic
    Fayetteville
    FBI
    FDA
    Fiction
    Fire
    Florida
    Free Market
    Fun
    Germany
    Gilmore
    Government
    Health Care
    Hillary Clinton
    Hobby
    Iraq
    Italy
    John Kasich
    Kevin Williamson
    Korea
    Kuwait
    LANTIRN
    Life
    Local Politics
    Marco Rubio
    Medical Care
    Memoir
    Military
    MIsfitMemo
    #MisfitMemo
    Misfits
    Misfits Politics
    Moms
    Mother's Day
    Narrative
    National Review
    NATO
    Navy
    #NeverTrump
    Patent
    Pharmaceutical
    Philippines
    Phillippines
    Politics
    Raymond
    Reform
    Rex
    Rubio
    Scarcity
    September 11th
    Service
    Ted Cruz
    Thread
    Tweetstorm
    Twitter
    UK
    Water
    Weekly Rewind
    World Cup
    World Trade Center

    RSS Feed

Home

About

Contact​

Copyright © 2016
  MisfitsPolitics
  • Home
  • Misfit Migrants
  • Mess Hall
  • Meet The Misfits
  • Misc. Musings
  • Home
  • Misfit Migrants
  • Mess Hall
  • Meet The Misfits
  • Misc. Musings